Rich investors pulling out of Chile, leaving behind a USD 50-billion hole in the economy

Post available in: English

Chile, Latin America’s stand-out economy for the better part of 50 years and a darling of Wall Street, is facing an existential moment in many ways.

Chile, Latin America’s stand-out economy for the better part of 50 years and a darling of Wall Street, is facing an existential moment in many ways.

Its Milton Friedman-inspired constitution is still intact, for now. But virtually everywhere you look, once sacrosanct pillars of the country’s free-market system — from its private pensions and health care to how much it taxes big business — are under attack following the election of its most leftist leader in decades.

This has had a chilling effect on the moneyed class here.

From the third floor of an expansive glass building in Santiago’s leafy El Golf neighbourhood, Juan Ignacio Correa, a partner at multi-family office Avante, recalled how many of his clients used to keep as much as 70 per cent of their wealth in local assets and only 30 per cent abroad, a level unheard of elsewhere in the region and a sign of trust in the country’s economic model. “Today, it’s exactly the opposite,” Correa said. “There is a fear of what is happening here.”

So abrupt is the shift in sentiment that, if left unchecked, it puts Chile at risk of becoming just one more troubled Latin American investment destination, akin to Brazil, Mexico or Colombia, if not quite a market pariah such as Argentina and Venezuela. Ever since millions of Chileans took to the streets in 2019 to protest gaping inequality — one of the most glaring shortcomings of the current system — and demand changes to free-market policies, investors have pulled more than US$50 billion from the country, according to Central Bank data through September. That equals about one-sixth of Chile’s annual economic output.

As President Gabriel Boric pushes to, in his words, “redistribute the wealth that Chileans produce,” money continues to flow out the door, though at a slower pace than before. With the country facing an unprecedented economic, social and political upheaval, Chile watchers say capital flight will significantly limit its ability to remain the dominant economic force in the region it once was.

“The new reality, in which investors, families and companies see that risks are higher, that the economy is vulnerable and that the political scenario is messy,” is permanently upending Chile’s home-bias advantage, said Sergio Lehmann, chief economist at Banco de Credito e Inversiones. It will “lead to lower levels of investment and therefore a lower long-term growth rate.”

A representative for Chile’s Finance Ministry declined to comment.

Granted, Boric’s ability to advance his populist agenda has taken a hit in recent months as his public approval rating sinks to an all-time low and criticism mounts over rising crime and accelerating inflation.

Yet for Chile’s upper class, that’s little comfort. The fear is not that Boric will simply come after their wealth but even more, so that his policies will weigh on an economy the Central Bank predicts could shrink as much as 1.75 per cent this year.

That stands in stark contrast to the so-called “miracle of Chile,” coined by Friedman to describe the nation’s rapid economic expansion after it pivoted to open market policies, including deregulation and privatisation in the 1970s and 1980s under dictator Augusto Pinochet. The approach survived leaders and parties of all political leanings after the nation turned toward democracy in the 1990s.

But it also helped fuel vast inequality and, more recently, fan social unrest. Despite years of steady economic growth, the country has one of the biggest gaps between rich and poor among the 38 nations in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

In recent months, many of Chile’s largest companies have also begun cutting their domestic exposure.

Empresa Nacional de Telecomunicaciones sold its fibre optics assets to a group including KKR & Co last year. In contrast, electricity provider Enel Chile sold its transmission lines to a unit of Canada’s Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan and Alberta Investment Management Corp. And SM Saam, a unit of the billionaire Luksic family’s Quinenco conglomerate, sold US$1 billion in port and logistics assets to Hapag-Lloyd.

As money from asset sales comes in, shareholders and executives have shown little interest in reinvesting. Companies in Chile’s 57-member IGPA index paid a record 10.9 trillion pesos (US$13.2 billion) in dividends in 2021 and another 10.6 trillion pesos in 2022, more than double the prior two years, according to Dolphin Markets.

The lack of new investment is damping the country’s long-term prospects.

Chile’s Central Bank lowered its trend growth forecast over the next decade to 2.1% from 2.8% in December. It also raised its forecast for the nation’s neutral interest rate to 3.75% from 3.5%.

“Chile is suffering a huge loss of competitiveness,” said Gonzalo Trejos, head of the strategy at private banker Quest Capital. “This means that things that look cheap right now may stay cheap for a long time.”

Slow return

Still, some say there are reasons for optimism. 

Chileans in September overwhelmingly rejected a new constitution supported by Boric that critics said would have restricted investment and growth, eroded essential checks and balances on power and led to a surge in fiscal spending.

“Due to the rejection of the new constitution and other processes that have been moderated, we have seen a slow return of money to Chile, especially for some opportunities in the local fixed-income market,” said Gonzalo Cordova, general manager of wealth management at LarrainVial.

Others like Avante’s Correa argue there’s little to suggest investors will return to domestic markets in a significant way anytime soon. 

“Most investors who took the capital out of Chile will never bring it back,” Correa said. “How do you rebuild the economy then? With new local wealth. New rich people. And that will take a long, long time.”

by Eduardo Thomson, Bloomberg

Contact the Gateway to South America team to learn about the best investment opportunities in the region. The company is a benchmark for foreign investors wishing to invest in Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay, providing expert advice on property acquisition and investment tours.

The Gateway Team – When You are Serious About Property

(Visited 303 times, 1 visits today)

About Gateway to South America

Established in 2006, Gateway to South America began as a single office in Buenos Aires. Since then, it has grown into a vibrant regional network, providing professional real estate marketing services to clients in Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Paraguay, Peru, and Uruguay. If you enjoy reading our news site, please share it on your social media!

Want an edge on investing in Latin America? Get our Investment News first: Join 39,400 subscribers without cost to our English, Spanish or Portuguese posts for the latest real estate news in LATAM useful for new and experienced investors. Please note, this subscription is for Investment News only, not properties for sale.

Post available in: English


Make a comment on this post

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • There are some good indicators here for this article in Chile.

    We here on the ground in Chile, selling real estate, are seeing a collapse 2019 of the real estate market.

    We are seeing prices drop on newly listed properties. People are getting desperate. The tourist market has also dropped significantly from the anticipated tourism traffic post covid. We are not seeing the return of the normal tourist traffic here specifically in the south of Chile where we typically see Argentinians and Europeans visiting and filling up restaurants cabanas and hotels.

    This is a big thing for middle class real estate investors since they have taken their capital and put it into rental property or in this case TOURISM BASED RENTALS. How much does this effect people in this market? Well for instance in Puerto Octay, Puerto Varas, Frutillar, or Entre Lagos (which is the gateway to Chile from Argentina), we are seeing empty restaurants and cabanas. Many of these property owners are only open for 3-4 months of the year (Nov/Dec to March/April). Ka-Ching! So we normally these properties and businesses squirreling away their annual income at the end of the tourist season. Now we see these people / business / investments facing bankruptcy and quick sale. No-Ka-Ching….

    Also the residential real estate (Lots/House and construction sectors) facing the same fate. The middle class just do not have the money to buy the 10s of 1,000s of vacant lots that came on the market after the violet riots of 2019. There was a definite uptick in lot sales after the riots and after the Chilean government released AFP funds (the equivalent of Social Security funds in the USA) for people during the covid. So what did people do with this glut of money? The bought vacant lots at inflated prices. Now they are stuck with out the funds necessary to build a house and stuck with a lot that is worth half the price it was when the market was up! If you give a kid money he will spend it, and boy did they.

    So there is an inside Chile take. The market is crashing and now is a great time to buy a property in Chile. Hey gotta remain positive!

Real Estate and Investment News from South America
Visit us on LinkedInVisit us on FacebookVisit us on TwitterVisit us on Pinterest